Minister of Safety and Security and Others v Ndlovu

Minister of Safety and Security and Others v Ndlovu (788/11) [2012] ZASCA 189; 2013 (1) SACR 339 (SCA) (30 November 2012)

THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA

JUDGMENT

Case No: 788/11

Reportable

In the matter between:

MINISTER OF SAFETY AND SECURITY FIRST APPELLANT

MINISTER OF JUSTICE AND CONSTITUTIONAL SECOND APPELLANT

DEVELOPMENT

and

NEVER NDLOVU RESPONDENT

Neutral citation: Minister of Safety & Security v N Ndlovu (788/11) [2012] ZASCA 189 (30 November 2012).

Coram: Ponnan, Bosielo and Petse JJA

Heard: 7 November 2012

Delivered: 30 November 2012

Summary: Claim for damages for unlawful detention following upon unlawful arrest ─ unlawfulness not ceasing when accused is brought before a reception court which remands him in custody without enquiring whether it is in the interests of justice to detain him further.

________________________________________________________________

ORDER

________________________________________________________________

On appeal from: Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown (Mageza AJ sitting as court of first instance):

1 The appeal is dismissed with costs, including the costs of two counsel to be paid jointly and severally by the appellants, the one paying the other to be absolved.

2 The following order is substituted for the order of the court below:

‘(1) Judgment is entered in favour of the plaintiff:

(a) against the first defendant for:

(i) payment of the sum of R55 000;

(ii) interest at the prescribed legal rate a tempore morae;

(iii) costs.

(b) against the first and second defendants jointly and severally, the one paying the other to be absolved, for:

(i) payment of the sum of R175 000;

(ii) interest at the prescribed legal rate a tempore morae;

(iii) costs.’

________________________________________________________________

JUDGMENT

________________________________________________________________

PETSE JA (Ponnan and Bosielo JJA concurring):

[1] This appeal concerns the issue whether or not the further detention of the respondent, Mr Never Ndlovu, for the period from 24 October to 31 October 2008 to await his trial on a charge of possession of suspected stolen property was unlawful. The Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown (Mageza AJ) held that it was and accordingly awarded the respondent damages. It subsequently granted the appellants leave to appeal against its judgment and order to this court. I shall say more about the terms of the order later.

[2] The determination of the issue arising in this appeal will best be understood against the backdrop of the facts that follow.

[3] On 21 October 2008, late in the afternoon, the respondent, a Zimbabwean national, received a telephone call from an acquaintance known as Golden, requesting him to meet the latter in the street in Joza Township, Grahamstown, where the respondent lived at the time. Golden also requested the respondent to bring with him a laptop that he had earlier that day handed to the respondent for the purposes of the latter to install a Windows Software Program.

[4] The respondent obliged, but unbeknown to him Golden was accompanied by eight police officers, under the command of Warrant Officer Van Ross, who were investigating a case concerning the theft of the laptop in question from the premises of Westbank in Grahamstown. The police officers, after a brief questioning of the respondent, seized the laptop and asked the respondent to lead them to his residence, which he did. There, four police officers conducted a search of the premises without a search warrant. They seized an assortment of the respondent’s property comprising, inter alia, computers, a television set, Tech DVD player, a LG flatron screen and miscellaneous computer accessories.

[5] The respondent was arrested and detained for being in possession of what the police said was suspected stolen property in contravention of s 36 of the General Law Amendment Act 62 of 1955. On 23 October 2008 he was brought before a so-called ‘reception court’ ─ about which more shall be said later ─ and remanded in custody to 30 October 2008 because a so-called ‘Bail Information Form’, completed by the police and contained in the police docket, reflected that the respondent had furnished a false address and consequently had no fixed address. For this reason, according to the police, the respondent was not to be released on bail. On 30 October 2008, the respondent was granted bail of R500 which was paid on his behalf the following day. His case was postponed yet again. On 9 December 2008 charges against the respondent were withdrawn and on 10 December 2008 his property, seized by the police, on the date of arrest, was released to him.

[6] On 21 April 2010 the respondent instituted proceedings against the appellants, the Minister of Safety and Security, as the first defendant and the Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development, as the second defendant in the high court for unlawful arrest and detention from 21 to 31 October 2008.

[7] The matter proceeded to trial before Mageza AJ. During the appellants’ case it was conceded on behalf of the first appellant that the arrest of the respondent on 21 October 2008 and his subsequent detention until 23 October 2008, when he was brought before the ‘reception court’, were unlawful. But the appellants persisted in their defence that the respondent’s unlawful detention ceased when the magistrate in the ‘reception court’ remanded the respondent in custody to 30 October 2008 for a bail application and legal aid. This appeal is thus only concerned with the lawfulness of his further detention from 24 to 31 October 2008. The case of the appellants was that from the time the magistrate issued the detention order the unlawful detention ceased.

[8] The high court found in favour of the respondent and granted judgment as follows:

‘1. Judgment is entered in favour of Plaintiff:

(a) in respect of the unlawful arrest, attendant contumelia and detention between the evening of the 21st to the morning of the 23rd October 2008, damages in the amount of R55 000.00.

(b) in respect of the unlawful detention in prison between the 24th October to 31st October 2008 for the sum of R175 000.00.

(c) The defendants are ordered, jointly and severally, to pay interest on the damages awarded in (a) and (b) above at the legal rate from a date fourteen days after date of this judgment to date of final payment.

(d) Costs of suit together with interest calculated at the legal rate from a date fourteen days after the allocator to the date of payment.’

[9] On the pleadings, the arrest and subsequent detention of the respondent were common cause. It was also not in dispute that the respondent was arrested at Extension 4, Grahamstown where he was found in possession of the goods seized by the police on suspicion that they had been stolen. At a subsequent pre-trial conference, held on 7 April 2011 in terms of rule 37(1) of the Uniform Rules, the appellants correctly accepted that they bore the onus to establish that the respondent’s arrest and detention were legally justified (see Minister of Law & Order & others v Hurley & another 1986 (3) SA 568 (A).

[10] In Zealand v Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development & another 2008 (6) BCLR 601 (CC) the Constitutional Court in affirming this principle said:

‘It has long been firmly established in our common-law that every interference with physical liberty is prima facie unlawful. Thus, once the claimant establishes that an interference has occurred, the burden falls upon the person causing that interference to establish a ground of justification.

. . .

There can be no doubt that this reasoning applies with equal, if not greater, force under the Constitution.’[1]

[11] Of the witnesses who testified at the trial only the evidence of Captain Green, who was, at the material time, the Sector Commander of the Detective Branch, Grahamstown and Mr Lionel Prince, the prosecutor who appeared for the State in the ‘reception court’ on 23 October 2008, is material. Captain Green testified that, as Sector Commander, he had eighteen investigating officers under him. When he received police dockets he would peruse them and allocate them to designated investigating officers. When he received the docket relating to the respondent, he observed that it contained no identity or passport number and that a visit by an officer to the address furnished by the respondent had established that the respondent was unknown and that this triggered what he called ‘red lights’ because the respondent was a Zimbabwean national. Contained in the docket was a document titled ‘Bail Information Form’, which had been completed by Constable Buthi. This ‘Bail Information Form’ was intended to assist the prosecutor at the respondent’s first appearance at court. The prosecutor was expected to evaluate the information contained in that form and then decide whether to consent or object to bail. The form recorded that the appellant be refused bail because he was considered a flight risk.

[12] Prince testified that he did not study the docket but merely perused the ‘Bail Information Form’. He said it was the responsibility of the control prosecutor, Ms Msesiwe, to study the docket, draw a charge-sheet and thereafter give it to the prosecutor in the ‘reception court’. He, upon receiving the docket, only read the ‘Bail Information Form’ and realised that bail was to be opposed. He then called the respondent’s case before a magistrate in the ‘reception court’ and applied for the case to be remanded. All of this he did without reference to the respondent. Without further ado the magistrate postponed the case for seven days.

[13] It is opportune to say something about the so-called ‘reception court’, which has since ceased to exist. This is a ‘court’ which at that time was solely dedicated to dealing with accused persons at their first appearance in court. All cases before it were postponed as a matter of course and as a rule it never entertained any bail applications. Neither did it embark on a judicial evaluation to determine whether it was in the interests of justice to grant bail nor, in this case, did it afford the respondent an opportunity to address it on the question of his eligibility to be released on bail.

[14] Msesiwe, who was said to have perused the docket to make a determination as to whether the respondent should be released (whether on bail or warning) or detained further, did not testify. Nor did Constable Buthi. The evidence does reveal that the arresting officers had been to the respondent’s residence where they conducted a search and seized some of the respondent’s goods at the time of his arrest. Accordingly there could have been no doubt about the respondent’s residential address. It is thus inexplicable why Buthi would have suggested that the respondent had no fixed abode and as a consequence that he posed a flight risk. Buthi was a crucial witness. Indeed that seemed to have been accepted by Green when he testified.

[15] The case of the appellants thus suffers fundamentally from evidentiary short-comings. First, Prince who applied for the postponement of the respondent’s case on 23 October 2008 did not, on a fair assessment of his evidence, read the contents of the docket. He solely relied on the police entry in the ‘Bail Information Form’ that the respondent should not be granted bail. Msesiwe, who was said to have read the docket was not called. Indeed Prince conceded under cross-examination that anyone properly applying their mind to the matter at hand would have realised that the respondent was not a flight risk. Nor was Buthi called, who was said to be the source of the entry in the ‘Bail Information Form’ that the respondent had furnished a false address. The inevitable consequence of these evidentiary short-comings is that the evidence of the appellants, who bore the onus to justify the deprivation of the respondent’s liberty, came nowhere near discharging that onus. Quite clearly had the police conscientiously performed their duties, given that the respondent’s freedom was at stake, they would have realised that the respondent had a fixed address and was thus not a flight risk. Moreover the appellants’ problems are also compounded by the fact that the respondent was granted bail on his second appearance before court even though his circumstances had not changed.

[16] In Minister of Law and Order v Kader 1991 (1) SA 41 (A) at 51A-C this court held:

‘. . . I consider, that when s 50(1) speaks of further detention for the purposes of trial being ordered by the court “upon a charge of any offence”, this does not contemplate that the matter would be ready for trial at the first appearance of the arrested person, or that a properly formulated charge must then be preferred against him . . . All that the section contemplates is that the purpose of the detention throughout must be to secure the attendance of the accused at his trial upon the charge, which, it is expected, will be preferred against him. It goes without saying that it is the function of the judicial officer to guard against the accused being detained on insubstantial or improper grounds and, in any event, to ensure that his detention is not unduly extended.’ (My emphasis.)

In this case it is common cause that the ‘reception court’ never embarked on any judicial evaluation because, as a matter of course, its function was merely to postpone cases and without, it would seem, enquiring whether or not an accused person ought to be detained pending a trial. It can thus hardly be contended that the unlawful detention of the respondent ceased when he was brought before the ‘reception court’ which ordered his further detention. It follows that this appeal must fail.

[17] It remains to deal with one final aspect. It was common cause before us that the order of the high court has to be corrected. Judgment was entered in favour of the respondent for his unlawful:

(a) arrest and detention for the period 21 to 23 October 2008 in the sum of R55 000; and

(b) detention for the period 24 to 31 October 2008 in the sum of R175 000.

Although the order does not make it plain, in respect of (a), judgment could only have been entered against the first appellant. That would also hold true in respect of the interest and costs that flow from that award. And in respect of (b), judgment, interest and costs ought to have been entered against the appellants jointly and severally. It is thus necessary that the order be amended to reflect that. To avoid further confusion it may simply be more convenient to set aside the order in its entirety and replace it with the correct order. Save for correcting the order, the appeal must otherwise be dismissed with costs including the costs of two counsel, it being agreed between the parties that the employment of two counsel was justified.

[18] The following order is made:

1 The appeal is dismissed with costs, including the costs of two counsel to be paid jointly and severally by the appellants, the one paying the other to be absolved.

2 The following order is substituted for the order of the court below:

‘(1) Judgment is entered in favour of the plaintiff:

(a) against the first defendant for:

(i) payment of the sum of R55 000;

(ii) interest at the prescribed legal rate a tempore morae;

(iii) costs.

(b) against the first and second defendants jointly and severally, the one paying the other to be absolved, for:

(i) payment of the sum of R175 000;

(ii) interest at the prescribed legal rate a tempore morae;

(iii) costs.’

_________________

X M PETSE

JUDGE OF APPEAL

Appearances:

Appellants: M J Louw SC

N J Sandi

Instructed by:

Nkuhlu Khondo Incorporated, Grahamstown

The State Attorney, Bloemfontein

Respondent: A Beyleveld SC

D Niekerk

Instructed by:

Whitesides, Grahamstown

Naudes Attorneys, Bloemfontein

[1] At para 25.
© 2016 Templeton Pops Mageza

764 thoughts on “Minister of Safety and Security and Others v Ndlovu

  1. Bdsm chat

    984056 809308This is something I in fact need to try and do a lot of analysis into, thanks for the post 348809

  2. Bdsm chat

    464784 240877New York Travel Tips […]below you will discover the link to some sites that we believe you should visit[…] 370649

  3. snmptn 2018 arsitektur undip

    844809 768771An intriguing discussion will probably be worth comment. I feel that you basically write a lot much more about this subject, it might become a taboo topic but normally consumers are inadequate to communicate in on such topics. To yet another. Cheers 81859

  4. pendaftaran cpns 2018-2019 di jambi

    182271 246833 An interesting discussion is worth comment. I believe which you need to write more on this subject, it may not be a taboo topic but generally people are not enough to speak on such topics. Towards the next. Cheers 789186

  5. Software gigi

    983823 694619Howdy! I just wish to give a huge thumbs up for the great information you may have here on this post. I will probably be coming back to your weblog for much more soon. 8432

  6. college of law1

    582307 407097Oh my goodness! an outstanding write-up dude. Thank you Nevertheless Im experiencing difficulty with ur rss . Do not know why Cannot register for it. Could there be any person obtaining identical rss difficulty? Anybody who knows kindly respond. Thnkx 595140

  7. SlowLucile

    I see you don’t monetize your page, don’t waste your traffic, you can earn additional bucks every month with very good adsense alternative for blogs like yours.
    For more info search in google: blackhatworren’s strategies

  8. personal injury lawyer Los Angeles

    What does this mean? In the practical sense, not
    much… but in the legal world, it works as a sort of sleight-of-hand that protects Uber
    in the event of a lawsuit. You see, under the
    law, employers are considered to be more responsible for the
    actions of their employees than they are for the actions of their independent
    contractors.
    Uber has used this argument to protect itself against third party plaintiffs many
    times, including in a lawsuit filed by the family of a young girl who was
    killed by an Uber driver while crossing the street.
    If they can use that defense against an innocent child, you can bet they’ll use it against you!

    However, this issue is still a legally hazy one.
    Strong legal precedent has not yet been established on this
    particular question, and different courts have come to different conclusions.
    Right now, the status quo seems to be that Uber drivers are considered employees in some areas,
    and independent contractors in others.
    Regardless, you can be certain that if you were hit by an Uber driver, the company will do
    what it can to avoid having to pay you a dime. In these
    situations, a personal injury attorney is more important than ever, and one
    with experiences in Uber cases is a definite plus.

    If you find yourself in an Uber accident, you should take the same steps that you should take after any automobile accident.

    These steps include protecting your own safety by getting out of the line of immediate danger and calling 911
    if anyone has been injured, remaining at the scene and sharing insurance information with any other drivers who
    were involved, calling the police if the accident is
    serious, and reporting it to your insurance company.

  9. click here

    These steps include protecting your own safety by getting out of the line of immediate danger and calling 911

  10. Pingback: latestvideo sirius557 abdu23na9543 abdu23na6

  11. Pingback: Google

  12. Pingback: app for pc download

  13. Pingback: apps for pc download

  14. Pingback: used laboratory equipment dealers

  15. Pingback: China USB flash drive

  16. Pingback: w88 thailand

  17. Pingback: reclaimed wood design tips

  18. Pingback: any assembly

  19. Pingback: reclaimed wood information

  20. Pingback: trahnet video voland seks

  21. Pingback: Google

  22. Pingback: trahnet gigporno trah_net_621 video seks

  23. Pingback: Disposal

  24. Pingback: otvaracie hodiny

  25. Pingback: free windows app download

  26. Pingback: free download for windows 8

  27. Pingback: app download for windows 8

  28. Pingback: laptop app free download

  29. DarrellBeids

    Вы спрашиваете, как в итоге трудных технологических процессов хрупкое стеклышко изменяет до неузнаваемости собственные качества. Для вас светит обнаружить для себя различные стеклоткани, обширно используемые в этническом хозяйстве и признать критерии неопасной работы с материалом. Вы познакомитесь с новым укрывным материалом, владеющим непревзойденными качествами. Вы спрашиваете, как в итоге трудных технологических http://textile.byethost7.com/ процессов хрупкое стеклышко изменяет до неузнаваемости собственные качества. Для вас светит обнаружить для себя различные стеклоткани, обширно используемые в этническом хозяйстве и признать критерии неопасной работы с материалом. Вы познакомитесь с новым укрывным материалом, владеющим непревзойденными качествами. Вас поразит знакомое сырьё и обычная разработка, которая привела к классному итогу. Вы воспримете свойства и выдающиеся качества тарпаулина и осмыслите основание его увеличивающейся с любым годом известности.

  30. ArewBrill

    Enter promocode forumuser and get 22$ for free!

    What is Crypto-Jackpot.com ?
    Crypto-Jackpot.com – is an online gambling website. Our main ambition is to put forward you the occasion to play online with virtual currencies safely and responsibly. Our work is to be the leading digital relief convention that anticipates market demands and delights our players via offering snappy, safe as houses, and joking essential readies games.

    How does Bitcoin Jackpot works?
    Each contender can furnish any amount of bitcoin in everyone bet. The amount advance affects the chance to win. Without considering the fact that winnerticket is chosen randomly, you can spread your unintentional to gain a victory in, having a larger share of the round.

    How to refill my balance?
    You can refill your poise on Down payment page. The minimal deposit amount is $50 (USD)

    How to withdraw funds?
    You can recall your compare on Pull out page. Our cut of withdrawal is 2%. Immature users need to alter a lodge in send away for to be skilful to retract your funds.

    How to utilization promotional code?
    You can handle promotional protocol in your chart page. You can put into practice promotional code not once!

  31. Darnellbig

    Доброго времени,друзья!

    Советую присмотреться к возможности

    Хватит жаловаться на правительство и начальника! Возьми жизнь в свои руки и заработай для свой семьи
    используя интернет!Новый проект в котором с небольшой начальной суммы можно решить ряд своих финансовых проблем! Ссылка снизу в подписи!

  32. KevinTet

    צריך העבורת דירה? מחפש חברת הובלות, הובלה בזול? 052-581-8132 סרגיי
    החברה שלנו יעזור לך לעשות את זה בקלות! הובלות, הובלות דירות
    איכותי, אמין במחירים סבירים! הובלות קטנות, הובלה זולה
    http://www.hovalot-a.a144.co.il – הובלות

  33. lightroomjes

    “https://adobe.com/” – Adobe Lightroom is the most everyday essence editing software in place of the long photographers, with hundreds of thousands of effects and presets within reach on the internet.

    You can download Lightroom from Adobe’s website.

    “https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_Lightroom” – Adobe Lightroom presets supporter you to redact your photos in relate term by means of doing a assignment of the work for you. You can altogether test old-fashioned a pre-defined really, while keeping your source image and reverting break to it at anytime.

    You can use:
    Lightroom Presets for Wedding Photography
    Lightroom Presets for Baby and Family Photography
    Lightroom Presets for Headshots
    Lightroom Presets for Senior Portraits
    Lightroom Presets for Landscape
    Lightroom Presets for Nature Photography
    Lightroom Presets for Food Photography
    Lightroom Presets for Car Photography
    Lightroom Presets for Real Estate
    Lightroom Presets for Product and Fashion Photography

    And a “https://mrlightroom.com/shop/lightroom-presets/eden-lightroom-desktop-and-mobile-presets/” – Eden Lightroom Desktop and Mobile Presets
    for everyday shooting.

  34. Rubenpulty

    Dear Friends!

    We’re the family of six who one day decided to sell the house and move to the sailing catamaran!
    We have changed our quiet and predictable everyday way of life to a new alternative lifestyle full of new discoveries, challenging situations, amazing sceneries and lots of fun!

    Join us at https://sailingmanakai.com and be welcomed aboard our floating home Mana Kai!

  35. angelinanow

    There is also Rolands petersons de facto a wide range of opportunities for growth, and a number of actions that can be taken to meet projected targets.Rolands petersons de facto There is a strong need for Rolands petersons de facto the services with high added value, the increase of the processed volumes of cargo by attracting new freight flows, high-quality Rolands petersons de facto passenger service and an introduction of modern technologies and information systems in the area of transit and logistics.Rolands petersons de facto Liepaja port has all the chances to become the second Rotterdam in the foreseeable future.Rolands petersons de facto

  36. affimerse

    Free full length lesbian sex video Lesbian foot fetish vids Annex gay bar san antonio fifty plus dating online sagittarius woman dating scorpio man online dating fraudsters best dating sites reviewsErotic lesbian short stories Video gay amateur site Chasey lane lesbian reno dating sites hook up greenspoint mall my love dating site zooks.com online dating & personals Lesbian 69 Blonde lesbian vids Gay lesbian parenting canada Annex gay bar san antonio 55 plus dating sites rules of dating me online dating tips for men over 40 love 2 meet dating siteElectric six gay bar un edited sandra bland mugshot Lesbian girlfriend pics Asexstories free lesbian stories dating my ex wife caribbean dating sites uk dating step sister diana penty dating harsha sagar Free lesbian hentai pictures
    Lesbian strp on Lesbian clubs in capitol hill seattle First lesbian se dating for the over 60s black women dating interracially average time of dating before marriage dating sites with no feesGay bar sag harbor ny Jada fire lesbian video Gay women chat rooms best first message on dating site dating a older girl hook up messenger vancouver dating app Brucie and dawnee lesbian

  37. olegnow

    Олег Колпаков директор школы.
    Главный человек в школе, это, конечно, директор!

    Директор нашей школы , молодой и энергичный, Олег

    Колпаков.

    Колпаков всегда живет заботами о школе. Даже

    летом, когда все на каникулах, Олег Колпаков

    находится на работе, он решает организационные

    вопросы, следит за проведением ремонтов, чтобы

    первого сентября ученики пришли в обновленные

    классы и с новыми силами приступили грызть гранит

    науки!
    Школа всегда живет заботами о воспитании и

    обучении учащихся. Это наша главная забота.

    Естественно и проблем хватает. Сегодня Колпаков не

    столько педагог, сколько организатор всего

    образовательного процесса. Чтобы ученики с

    радостью спешили на уроки, а учителям комфортно

    работалось, Олег Колпаков создает соответствующие

    условия.Олег Колпаков Работал В разных школах, и

    всегда гордился своими учениками и

    предподовательским составом.

  38. DennisCusia

    Предлагаю Интернет Рекламу от 10 usd за Месяц http://1541.ru Размещение Вашего Объявления на Доски Объявлений, форумы. Обучение. Что льзя и нельзя. Поисковая оптимизация ( лучше гугла) Все виды услуг по Pinterest + YouTube. В интернет рекламе 25 лет Skype evg7773 Viber +380976131437

  39. LaverneShund

    Your forum seemed to me exact inviting and promising.
    I demand to accept ads in favour of a month. Where should I play down to get a quote?

  40. mahaskurkina

    Бизнес есть бизнес .... Как зарегестрироваться на форуме бизнесменов.

  41. DennisCusia

    Ламинин Норвежский Купить от д-ра Эскеланда http://1541.ru в 4 раза Дешевле ( опт в 6 раз Дешевле), чем американский Laminine LPGN. Skype evg7773 Viber +380976131437

  42. Alinatardy

    Привеиствую Вас! Возможно будет интересно узнать то что недавно открылась потрясающая биржа ссылок “Не палим” для продвижения сайтов dark тематик:
    adult, загрузчики контента, ставки, pharm, а так же white сайты.
    Если интересно, можете детальнее ознакомиться с информацией у них в сообществе вк https://vk.com/nepalim_links !
    Извините если отняла у вас много времени )))
    Просто подумала их немного попиарить т.к. реально хорошая биржа ссылок))

  43. AndrewWaymn

    Чаще всего онлайн голосования требуют наличие нового(уникального) ip чтобы каждого посетителя, кто хочет оставить частный голос. Ради меня это не проблема. Использую ip адреса реальных людей, а не прокси сервера, которые легко вычислить. Также ip будут взяты именно нужной Вам страны, дабы не получилось, сколько в голосовании, которое проходит в России были голоса из Китая и прочих стран.

    Ради каждого сайта пишу отдельную программу по накрутке и с помощью её все делаю.

    Стандартные возможности программы это многопоточность т.е. возможность одновременно голосовать с разных ip. Это нужно чтобы того, для увеличить скорость накрутки опроса, ежели такая нужда есть. Если же надобности в быстрой накрутке голосований вышли, то дозволительно все совершать в взаперти поток.

    Также учитываю однако требования, дабы сам действие накрутки был естественным. Это следовательно который посетитель не простой нажмет на кнопку голосования, только также побудет для странице, прокрутит вверх-вниз страницу. Буде нуждаться перейдет для другую случайную страницу на данном сайте.
    http://a-smm.ru/

    Дабы еще больше обезопасить Вас, дозволительно извлекать несколько источников переходов для страницу голосований. Обычно моментально непосредственно переходят на страницу накрутки онлайн голосования и это вызывает недоверие у судей. Я же могу предложить разные источники, помимо прямого захода можно пользоваться любую ссылку для стороннем сайте для данное голосование. Также позволительно входить для страницу сквозь поисковые системы. Отбор не ограничен. Тем самым Вы намного больше защищены в часть, что Вас уличат в накрутке и снимут с участия в голосовании.
    Коли ради каждого онлайн проголосовавшего нужен новый емейл адрес, то это не проблема. Могу пользоваться свою базу емейлов(порядка 50 тыс), либо могу чтобы каждого пользователя регистрировать частный ящик. Это все можно обсудить и не составляет проблемы.

    Для счет количества голосов в сутки, то оно может добиваться десятки тысяч проголосовавших в сутки.

    Разве у Вас есть какие то другие пожелания по накрутке, то постоянно обсудим и расскажу дозволительно ли это сделать.

    Обычные накрутчики голосований нуль подобного не предлагают.

    Объясню схему работы.

    1 — Вы показываете мне сайт, на котором идет голосование разве находится рейтинг

    2* — оплачиваете нужное наличность голосов

    3 — я произвожу накрутку

    * Если Вы вдруг сомневаетесь в моей честности, то дозволено заказать 100 голосов для проверки. Также я имею персональный(т.е. подтвержденный документами) удостоверение вебмани и ради особо не верующих могу открыть рацион персональных данный.
    накрутка голосований форум
    накрутка голосования facebook
    накрутка в голосовании в вк
    прога для накрутки голосований
    накрутка голосов в анонимном голосовании

  44. PhilipSek

    Станьте партнером byweb и получайте ВОЗНАГРАЖДЕНИЕ до 30% с каждого платежа привлеченного клиента за создание сайта.

    Если вы привлекли клиента для создания сайта для нас, пожалуйста, укажите имя клиента в нашей обратной связи

    Найти НАС МОЖНО в ЛЮБОМ ПОИСКОВИКЕ очень легко ПО ЗАПРОСУ:

    “создание и продвижение сайтов в Москве byweb”

    Ниже контекстной рекламы будет наш сайт: Sozdaniesa…

    С уважением,
    Digital-агентство ByWeb
    Создание и продвижение сайтов в Москве

  45. Marcusunsub

    Между обилия передовых тканей довольно непросто устроить выбор. Охота, дабы ткань в одно и тоже время был плавным, приятным на ощупь, экологически незапятнанным и при данном ещё обычным в уходе. Не обращая внимания на эти, казалось бы, строгие запросы многая прогрессивная продукция соответствует им. Раздел вебсайта под http://textile.wikidot.com/ заглавием «про ткани» имеет исчерпающую информацию. Тут возможно признать большое количество свежего как протекстиль ткани в традиционном варианты, например и о новинках. Искусственного происхожденияИскусственные ткани используют большущий известностью. Впрочем, их многообразие несколько затрудняет выбор. Казалось бы, о чем тут болеть любой имеет возможность избрать на личный вкус и доход, впрочем, не все например элементарно. Дабы устроить верный выбор нужно разобраться в свойствах продукта.

  46. tarasnow

    Внимание вор!!!Тарасов Василий Михайлович 26.06.1990
    Василий Тарасов знакомился через интернет с женщинами, очаровывал их, укладывал в постель. А утром, пока жертвы еще спали, Тарасов похищал деньги, драгоценности и скрывался. На счету Тарасова уже нескеолько жертв.

    Обе они стали жертвами Василия Тарасова, с которым незадолго до инцидента познакомились на просторах интернета. У одной потерпевшей Тарасов похитил компьютер стоимостью 50 000 рублей, у другой – шкатулку с золотыми и жемчужными украшениями, причинив ей ущерб на 40 000 рублей
    Тарасов Василий Михайлович опасен, будте внимательны!!!

    Контакты: Тарасов Василий Михайлович 26.06.1990
    9162495865
    razdel115@yandex.ru

  47. Otelunamy

    Недорогой отель Владимирский находится рядом с центром Нижнего Новгорода. Ближайшая станция метро Ленинская находится в 640 м от гостиницы, что позволяет попасть в центр города за 10-15 минут. Гостиница располагается в Нижнем Новгороде рядом с ЖД вокзалом.

    Гостиница в Нижнем Новгороде

  48. auto loan

    [url=https://carfinance.us.org/]wells fargo auto finance[/url] [url=https://carfinancing.us.org/]car financing[/url] [url=https://autofinancing.us.org/]auto financing[/url] [url=https://autorefinance.us.org/]refinance auto[/url] [url=https://autoloan.us.org/]auto loan rates[/url]

  49. CecilTox

    Железнодорожные перевозки. Анналы возникновения и развития
    Теперь грузовые железнодорожные перевозки представляют собой симбиоз инженерных достижений в области средств передвижения и оптимального процесса управления продвижением товаров и услуг через поставщиков к потребителям. Железнодорожные превозки. ТК БИРТРАНСЖелезнодорожные перевозки грузов по-прежнему считаются самым быстрым, удобным и наименее затратным способом доставки различных грузов – от тяжелой строительной техники перед скоро портящихся продуктов питания.Объясняется это в первую очередь тем, сколько железнодорожные перевозки находятся вне конкуренции, если филиппика соглашаться о транспортировке тяжелых и негабаритных грузов: строительной техники (кранов, экскаваторов, самосвалов), крупногабаритных технических изделий (предположим, опор ЛЭП, железобетонных плит, перекрытий и т.п.). Железнодорожные превозки. ТК БИРТРАНС Около этом размеры данных грузов ограничены только размерами самого подвижного состава, какой довольно исполнять железнодорожную перевозку. Более того – современная строительная техника целенаправленно проектируется именно с расчетом для то, который ее доставка будет осуществляться железнодорожным транспортом.
    Для всем протяжении цивилизации индивидуальность навсегда задумывался, чем ему перетащить иначе перевезти тяжеловесный, крупногабаритный, правда и весь любой бремя, какой он один не в состоянии перенести. Беспричинно были изобретены простые транспортные средства, сиречь сани, повозка, плот, лодка. Когда усилие человека в качестве тяговой силы уже было не достаточно, люди стали извлекать животных: волов, верблюдов и, понятно же, лошадей.
    Паки в Древней Греции существовала необходимость перевозки тяжеловесного и негабаритного груза. Для сокращения водного пути из Саронического залива в Коринфский существовал каменный курс, называемый Диолком с глубокими желобами в качестве направляющих и кто служил чтобы перемещения волоком тяжелых кораблей.

    перевозка опасных грузов железнодорожным транспортом

  50. Matthewglimi

    Мойка Авто насухую за 3 мин! http://sunnymlm.ru/ecology01.htm Автополотенце LUXE из новейшего микроволокна. Производство Япония. Впитывает любую грязь, масло и т.д. Цены Лучшие и возможность Заработка. И Другие изделия из микроволокна +79161414123 Skype: vsunnymlm

  51. Ameliias

    You know your forum is not about that, but I’m watching you for a long time and decided to register.
    Well, to write…

    I will write at Once-I want to meet a decent man!
    My name is Alena, not married, I’m 27 years old and I’m from Moscow.

    This is me)))
    https://goo.gl/GFDjir

  52. BradyGyday

    918Kiss Online download link
    918Kiss
    918Kiss Register
    918Kiss download apk
    918Kiss download ios

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.